S2 Ep44: Ep. 44 - The Murder of the Caffey Family

The slaughter of the Caffey family was brutal and senseless. Penny Caffey and her two young sons, Matthew and Tyler we murdered in their home in March, 2008. Terry Caffey and his older daughter Erin Caffey both survived the massacre, but it would soon come to light that one of them was involved in the tragedy that took place. Listen for more details and explicit comments by Terry Caffey himself. Sources: 1.) https://allthatsinteresting.com/erin-caffey 2.) https://murderpedia.org/female.C/c/caffey-erin.htm 3.) https://www.hsinvisiblechildren.org/when-homeschoolers-turn-violent/erin-caffey/ 4.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoszkY3hMsM 5.) https://www.vizaca.com/erin-caffey-story/ 6.) https://www.oxygen.com/killer-couples/crime-news/erin-caffey-charlie-wilkinson-family-murder-dad-terry Check out our socials for more content from us: MERCH IS HERE Instagram Buy me a Coffee TikTok: @brantyyy_ and @southern.math.teacher Email Us: [email protected] **Ashleigh misspoke when discussing the relation of this case to the Paris Lee Bennett case, she meant to say that Paris' mother was still fostering a relationship with Paris throughout his trial and after he was sent to prison**